HADDONFIELD, N.J. - The legal odyssey for an
18-year-old who fatally stabbed her father with a kitchen knife
during an argument ended Wednesday when a grand jury decided not to
indict her.
"Legally, it's a good day," said Jasmine Karo's lawyer, Robert
DePersia. "Setting that aside, there are a lot of issues to deal
with."
The teenager had broad support in the tight-knit Philadelphia
suburb of Gloucester City, particularly among community members who
said her father, Alan Karo, was abusive and an alcoholic.
After learning she would not face a murder trial, Karo told
reporters she wants her experience to teach others "not to be
ashamed if you're in an abusive family. Have faith in yourself and
be strong."
She now lives with a mother who has struggled with alcohol and a
12-year-old sister who was there when her father was stabbed last
month. Karo is still the main breadwinner for the family.
Faye Fulginiti, a counselor at Highland Park Alternative School,
from which Karo graduated this week, said Karo had been abused for
years.
"The abuse was probably worse than any of the other cases I had
heard about," Fulginiti said.
Authorities said the argument at Karo's home on May 6 began after
she took a telephone to her basement bedroom because she was
expecting a call from her boyfriend. Her father, they said, had been
drinking all day and showed his anger by throwing the phone at
her.
The teen told prosecutors she later heard her father arguing with
and pushing her mother, Margaret Smiley, who is Karo's girlfriend of
20 years.
The father ended up putting the daughter in a headlock. At some
point, she reached for the knife and stabbed him in the
shoulder.
When she returned home that night, police were there to arrest
her on murder charges. The community quickly rallied around her.
Teachers raised money to buy her a bedroom set. On Monday, her
school presented her an award for courage and tenacity, along with
her diploma.
Several lawyers offered to handle the case pro bono. Camden
County Prosecutor Vincent P. Sarubbi lowered bail voluntarily, and
state Assemblyman Joseph Roberts posted the bond.
Sarubbi's top assistant also took the unusual step of asking Karo
if she wanted to testify. She told reporters that she was asked
about past confrontations with her father.
Within three hours, the grand jury decided not to indict.
Karo seemed more relieved than happy that she would not be facing
a murder trial, though she said she was glad to tell her little
sister, Priscilla, that she would not be going to prison.